CWA News


Experts highlight impact of climate change on fish and small ruminants

October 8, 2014

Three agriculture and fisheries experts have warned of the impact of climate change on fish and small ruminants, two important protein sources in the region. Their statements were made during the 13th Caribbean Week of Agriculture (CWA), being held in Paramaribo, Suriname, from October 6-10.

Susan Singh-Renton, deputy executive director of the Caribbean Regional Fisheries Mechanism, said on Monday October 6, that as the temperature of the Caribbean Sea rises, species of fish found in the region may move further northward.

"This is referring specifically to the large fish that are very mobile, and some of them are warm water species, so the sea surface temperature provides a natural boundary to their range and, normally, we will find these species distributed just within the tropical seas and they are accessible to us as a result," she said, adding that these species include dolphin fish, kingfish, and some tunas.
"What you will find is that if you have a warming of sea water, then that natural range of the fish becomes extended and [the fish] are able to move away; they move northward," she said in an interview.

Singh-Renton was speaking on the sidelines of a workshop titled "Improving Climate Change Resilience in the Small Ruminants and Fisheries Industries in the Caribbean".

The workshop was co-organised by the Technical Centre for Agricultural and Rural Cooperation (CTA), the Caribbean Agricultural Research and Development Institute (CARDI), CRFM and other agricultural agencies.
The workshop forms part of the 13th Caribbean Week of Agriculture, taking place here until Friday, under the theme "Transforming Caribbean Agriculture Through Family Farming".

Singh-Renton said experts have seen that in certain years, species of fish found in warmer waters such as the Caribbean are caught outside their normal range. "We had recorded lower catches in those years," she added.
Singh-Renton also noted that there are factors that increase the population of these fish, but experts have not determined the cause. "But sometimes you have the productivity plumes from the river outflows -- from the Amazon and the Orinoco. As the river flows, that productivity changes, and the fish are following the food. So depending on the direction of that flow, if some things, for example, [if] currents, change that flow and take it away from the islands, then those fish will not become available," she said.

Singh-Renton noted that it is difficult to determine the impact of climate change on food security and that of lower fish catches on the economy of the region, adding: "There is a lot that we don't understand about the biology and ecology of these resources and what triggers the migration patterns.

"But certainly, if these fish are less available to our fisherman, we will see less fish production," she said, adding that this will be the case unless fisher folk invest in technologies that allow them to go further to catch those fish.

"And you have to remember now that you may be entering foreign jurisdiction, in terms of you will need agreements to enter some other countries' waters, for example, if that becomes the case," she said.

Norman Gibson, small ruminants commodity leader at the Caribbean Agricultural Research and Development Institute, said in a separate interview on the sideline of the same workshop, that there are two critical issues relating to the impact of climate change on small ruminants.
"Small ruminants represent [an] important commodity in the region's food stocks," he said, adding that in many countries they are the meat of choice.
He noted that in Trinidad and Guyana, there are some religious festivals that demand the use of either sheep or goats.

"We know that, in the region, in terms of nutrition security, it is a commodity that we have to give some attention to, given how much it is already being used in our cuisine, how much it is demanded by the local population, and the fact that it is actually a much better product than what we import from New Zealand and Australia, in terms of flavour and other characteristics," Gibson said.

He said climate change now brings "a new dimension to everything we do in agriculture, and the thinking is that if we are going to continue to improve small ruminant production, then we have to consider the impact of climate change and what that will do to existing stocks and whether or not farmers are prepared, at this point, to meet those challenges," Gibson explained.
"So, when we consider food and nutrition security in the region, we think of all the things that go into that basket. And, of course, small ruminants is one... And climate change affects everyone, therefore we have to consider all commodities in the context of climate change," Gibson added.

He said that the higher temperatures that result from climate change cause small ruminants to become more stressed, "especially in the context of the Caribbean where in a lot of systems, animals are roaming outside or often grazing in pastures without water during the course of the day."

Gibson said that as animals become more stressed, they eat less."It means that they begin to have respiratory issues, and therefore, as a consequence, they don't put on as much meat, they don't produce as much milk..." he said, adding that there may also be saline intrusion into pastures as a result of climate change, making small ruminants less productive.

Gibson explained that while small ruminants might survive extreme weather like hurricanes, the impact may be seen weeks later.

"One of the things that we have noticed is that when you have intense activity, hurricanes and so on, small ruminants tend to sense the intense activity. Thereafter you begin to see the effects, in a few weeks after the storm has passed."

"Because of increased stress brought on by the event, they have more problems with parasites and so on. And the mortality rates can actually be quite high as a consequence of those things," he said.

Dr. Olu Ajayi, senior programme coordinator -- agricultural and rural development policy at CTA, pointed out that morbidity among small ruminants has implications not only for food security.

"These are not just sources of protein alone. For farmers, this is a kind of asset; so you have negative implications on the income and the asset base of farmers," he said.
Ajayi noted also that the impacts of climate change may vary among locations, adding that there is still much that experts do not know. He said responses must be based on local needs, but added that there are several principles that can be applied across regions.

"So we need a strong, robust information base; we also need the kind of good policies that take into account the issue of climate change and how to respond to it. For example, we need a deliberate effort in the policy arena to promote climate smart livestock, climate smart fishing methodologies and practices. We also need dialogue, strong partnerships among different organisations who can bring something to the table," he said, adding that this is necessary to create synergies and avoid duplication of efforts.

Climate smart agriculture helps to increase productivity, enabling agriculture to adapt to changing climate, and minimising greenhouse gas emissions, Ajayi pointed out.
"Any technologies or practices in agriculture that help to accomplish these three things are very key. We have the same thing for crop, livestock, and fish."
Ajayi added that climate smart livestock in the Caribbean could mean modifying structures where livestock is housed, so as to help the animals survive heat stress.

He noted that one farmer had told the workshop that "a strange disease" had wiped out a significant part of his livestock within a few days. However, it was later determined that the "strange disease" was in fact heat stress, Ajayi said.

"So it is very important that we understand the kind of heat stress on the animals," he added.

Kenton X. Chance