As Regional Manager for Structured Trading Systems at the Eastern Africa Grain Council, Samwel Rutto’s work entails promoting structured markets to facilitate trade and eliminating inefficiencies in the grain industry. Here he explains how his experience in the design and operation of an electronic grain trading system has taught him some of the pitfalls to avoid when trying to scale up digital marketing platforms for agribusiness.Read More
A market information service delivered by mobile phone is helping to promote transparency in Senegal, enabling farmers to obtain fairer prices for their products – including producers who have not signed up for the service.
“The key thing is to have negotiating power. With these text messages, we feel better equipped, more confident. When I see the information on my mobile phone, and a bana-bana (middleman) arrives offering a lower price, I tell all the other farmers not to sell. I let the bana-bana talk and when he finishes, I tell him I know the true price.
Lamine Sagna, a cashew farmer in the Sedhiou region of southern Senegal, has learned first-hand that knowledge is power. He is one of a growing number of farmers who have subscribed to N’kalô, a market information service operating in Burkina Faso, Côte d’Ivoire, Mali and Senegal, and supported by CTA during a scaling up phase. The service delivers weekly bulletins to farmers and their organisations by mobile phone, supplying valuable information about the market situation and trends for a particular crop, including the prices it may be expected to fetch.
An information gathering network
Each week, the N’kalô team collects information by telephoning and emailing a large network of private players – farmers, traders, processors – at local, but also international level, and chatting with them on WhatsApp. After analysing the market situation and prospects, the team sends advisories to thousands of farmers, mainly through text messages sent by mobile phone.
“When I receive messages, I feel stronger. I tell the middlemen: ‘Take it or leave it. Someone else will come and buy it’, and they are forced to take my product,” said André Sadio, a farmer in Senegal’s Ziguinchor region and user of the service.
A knock-on effect of N’kalô has been better business for all farmers, including those who have not signed up for the bulletins. That is because traders have no way of knowing which producers receive the text messages, and which do not. As a result, they are reluctant to offer prices that are too low, for fear of compromising their credibility.
“Before, we would only receive information from middlemen, who fixed prices between each other,” explained Karamouko Toure, a cashew farmer in Senegal’s Kolda region. “Now, the simple fact that the bana-bana, who come here on a regular basis, know that we receive information via N’kalô helps to ensure that the price they offer is fairer throughout the whole village.”
Better market information helps to save time and transport costs, since negotiations are easier and are more likely to reach a successful conclusion.
“It helps things to go faster,” said Bacary Mangdien, Coordinator of the AJAC Cooperative of sesame farmers in Sedhiou region. “We negotiate less, and discussions take place on a healthier basis.”
Shall I sell, or should I wait?
Messages sent through N’kalô include advice and forecasts based on price trends, helping farmers and farmer organisations to refine their short and mid-term marketing strategies, and decide whether it is worth waiting before selling their produce.
A case in point was a recent decision by maize farmer Ibrahima Diop to delay sales amid forecasts of increasing price trends. “This year we had a small stock of maize that we held for longer, because the text messages warned us of a possible increase,” said Diop, who is Treasurer of the Yachalal Cooperative in Sokone region. “We sold in April at a good price (210 FCFA/kg or €0.32/kg), which enabled the cooperative to make a profit.” The Senegalese Federation of Sesame Farmers (FENPROSE) recently signed a contract for the 2018/2019 season with a foreign exporter, on the understanding that prices used for each transaction will be based on N’kalô figures.
Many N’kalô users report having improved relationships with clients throughout the value chain, due to the widespread availability of reliable and objective market information. Leaders of farmer organisations say the service is helping to build trust and discussion within their membership. Overall, farmers in Senegal agree that the market information service has led to a better business climate.
“N'kalô reminds me of the Chinese proverb that ‘if someone is in need, rather than giving fish to eat, it is better to teach him how to fish’,” observed Amath Diouf, a cashew farmer and trader in Sokone region. "That’s because people learn to understand markets. But in addition, N'kalô also provides fish, because farmers often earn higher prices just by mentioning the messages to buyers.”
This article was created through a CTA-led process to document and share actionable knowledge on 'what works' for ACP agriculture. It capitalises on the insights, lessons and experiences of practitioners to inform and guide the implementation of agriculture for development projects.